I and dh watched the show when it aired...both of us waiting to see how they would portray Islam. The Iman did a great job...but of course the emphasis was on the other guy. Also he offered up that none but Allah knows who will ultimately go to paradise...something in that respect. I have to admitt that the view of sex and wine and wordly desires in paradise still sits on me very strangely...probably from my background and I am sure that when other christians heard this it probably sat weird with them too.
In retrospect, imagine the good that probably fell to the cutting room floor of the Imam's comments...*sigh*...while unnecessary focus went to the comments of the man imprisoned for his attempt at suicide bombing...noticeably missing were the interviews of imprisoned Catholic priests paying for the crimes they've committed against innocent children; victims of molestation, a crime for which any ordinary citizen would pay for in spades. News reports about these will be far and few between as the offending priests aren't prosecuted...they're just shuffled around from one parish to another. In order to find justice, molestation cases are thus taken into the courts, where the Archdioceses then proceeds to enter into financial settlement agreements. The next twist, as in the case of an Archdiocese in Portland, Oregon, after entering into huge monetary settlement agreements, the Archdiocese turns right around and files for bankruptcy protection!
FACT: 27 February 2004 - A report commissioned by the Church says more than 4,000 US Roman Catholic priests had faced sexual abuse allegations in the last 50 years, in cases involving more than 10,000 children - mostly boys.
Eye-opening timeline of scandal can be read here: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/3872499.stm.
There is even a website (SNAP) - Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests devoted to helping the abused (http://www.snapnetwork.org/).
Sad, too sad!!
I thought about all that when I wrote the article...but I didn't want its message to be diminished by turning it into a religion bashing piece, you know what I mean? But that doesn't change the fact that the whole scandal makes me feel angry and disappointed.
With regard to the attributes of paradise...Allahu Alam.
I too saw this story and had a very similar reaction as you. It was definately very interesting, but I was so very disappointed that Barbara chose to entertain the bombing suspect's misguided views of Paradise, mash'Allah... At least she did interview the imam, but, the editing did not allow his point of view to make a substantial impact following the first young brother's comments.
It just seems to me that after years of world travel and journalistic exposure to the world, one would have approached this topic with regard to Muslims differently. Oh well, the propaganda continues...
Great article, Aishah. I truly enjoyed it, and agree with you!
True to fact when Mrs.Walters does a show I allways hog the t.v.,but just with the previews of the show my smile turned to a frown. I'm sure the producers of 20/20 knew millions would be watching this show because so many at this time are unsure and totaly confused. My thing is that she(Mrs.Walters) could have easily talked to someone else,but I guess its easy to make it negative then it is for it to be positave. Maybe if enough muslims would make it known to her this was wrong,and have muslims on that can maybe shine a better light and get questions from non muslims who want to learn Islaam and not hate it;Then we could all turn this misrepresentaion of Islaam around. Am I dreaming when I say that I want people to love and live Islaam? Well if it were a dream then it would be true and no need to ask.
I too was disappointed at the depiction of Muslims in this 20/20 special report - I thought once again, "here we go." I found it interesting that they picked a suicide bomber out of all the Muslims in the world they could have interviewed. Also, while the Imam did do a wonderful interview, I felt that in the end it seemed he agreed with the suicide bomber, although by that time I could tell it was the way they had perhaps edited things. It was very disappointing from that perspective.
How sad we are shown in a bad light again. When will the media print the "TRUTH OF ISLAM"???
No wonder some times when I travel about the USA I am stared at, cussed at and things like this. And attacted twice just for the scare I wear on my head. Thank you media for this !!!!
If only the media would start printing the similarities about the religion of Christians, Jews and Muslims. Instead of trying to show such a difference. We all want the right to worship our God as our religions request us to do. We all want a peaceful life. We all want to love and respect our parents. We all want the right to raise our children to love God. We all want a good quality of life by working hard. We all are taught to stay away from evil. IF WE PRACTICED OUR RELIGIONS FAITHFULLY (ISLAM, JUDISM, CHRISTIANITY, OTHER RELIGIONS) THERE WOULD BE NO WAR, NO SUICIDE BOMBINGS, THINGS OF THIS NATURE !!! THERE WOULD BE LESS PEOPLE STARVING IN THE WORLD AND HOMELESS. WE WOULD LIVE IN PEACE WITH OUR NEIGHBORS!!!
Aishah this is truly a good article. And yes I agree bringing up the Priests would take away from the whole point of your article. Which is...Islam and the truth of Heaven of which the Imam was definately not allowed to bring out by the time editing was done.
We need to pray for our media leaders...if only more positive stories were printed in this world, peoople would have the hope that our God allows us !!!
I too had seen the TV broadcast of this and had hoped to see some 'good' points for Islam. Well, as many of you had said... it was a bit disapointing that editing has taken the place of truth and free speech. Isn't it amazing how careful editing has turned the story upon itself. The iman was an intelligent man, who seems to want to educate people - but the editors/producers of the show seemed to want to just further the misconception of Islam. Well so be it... all we can pray for is that a few people were enlightened to what true Islam is.
I and dh watched the show when it aired...both of us waiting to see how they would portray Islam. The Iman did a great job...but of course the emphasis was on the other guy. Also he offered up that none but Allah knows who will ultimately go to paradise...something in that respect. I have to admitt that the view of sex and wine and wordly desires in paradise still sits on me very strangely...probably from my background and I am sure that when other christians heard this it probably sat weird with them too.
ReplyDeleteWa'Alaikum Assalamu,
ReplyDeleteIn retrospect, imagine the good that probably fell to the cutting room floor of the Imam's comments...*sigh*...while unnecessary focus went to the comments of the man imprisoned for his attempt at suicide bombing...noticeably missing were the interviews of imprisoned Catholic priests paying for the crimes they've committed against innocent children; victims of molestation, a crime for which any ordinary citizen would pay for in spades. News reports about these will be far and few between as the offending priests aren't prosecuted...they're just shuffled around from one parish to another. In order to find justice, molestation cases are thus taken into the courts, where the Archdioceses then proceeds to enter into financial settlement agreements. The next twist, as in the case of an Archdiocese in Portland, Oregon, after entering into huge monetary settlement agreements, the Archdiocese turns right around and files for bankruptcy protection!
FACT: 27 February 2004 - A report commissioned by the Church says more than 4,000 US Roman Catholic priests had faced sexual abuse allegations in the last 50 years, in cases involving more than 10,000 children - mostly boys.
Eye-opening timeline of scandal can be read here: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/3872499.stm.
There is even a website (SNAP) - Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests devoted to helping the abused (http://www.snapnetwork.org/).
Sad, too sad!!
I thought about all that when I wrote the article...but I didn't want its message to be diminished by turning it into a religion bashing piece, you know what I mean? But that doesn't change the fact that the whole scandal makes me feel angry and disappointed.
With regard to the attributes of paradise...Allahu Alam.
Ma'Salaama.
As salaamu alaikkum,
ReplyDeleteI too saw this story and had a very similar reaction as you. It was definately very interesting, but I was so very disappointed that Barbara chose to entertain the bombing suspect's misguided views of Paradise, mash'Allah... At least she did interview the imam, but, the editing did not allow his point of view to make a substantial impact following the first young brother's comments.
It just seems to me that after years of world travel and journalistic exposure to the world, one would have approached this topic with regard to Muslims differently. Oh well, the propaganda continues...
Great article, Aishah. I truly enjoyed it, and agree with you!
Ma salaam,
Kimberly
As salaamu Alaikum,
ReplyDeleteTrue to fact when Mrs.Walters does a show I allways hog the t.v.,but just with the previews of the show my smile turned to a frown.
I'm sure the producers of 20/20 knew millions would be watching this show because so many at this time are unsure and totaly confused.
My thing is that she(Mrs.Walters) could have easily talked to someone else,but I guess its easy to make it negative then it is for it to be positave.
Maybe if enough muslims would make it known to her this was wrong,and have muslims on that can maybe shine a better light and get questions from non muslims who want to learn Islaam and not hate it;Then we could all turn this misrepresentaion of Islaam around.
Am I dreaming when I say that I want people to love and live Islaam? Well if it were a dream then it would be true and no need to ask.
I too was disappointed at the depiction of Muslims in this 20/20 special report - I thought once again, "here we go." I found it interesting that they picked a suicide bomber out of all the Muslims in the world they could have interviewed. Also, while the Imam did do a wonderful interview, I felt that in the end it seemed he agreed with the suicide bomber, although by that time I could tell it was the way they had perhaps edited things. It was very disappointing from that perspective.
ReplyDeleteSalam Alaikum:
ReplyDeleteHow sad we are shown in a bad light again. When will the media print the "TRUTH OF ISLAM"???
No wonder some times when I travel about the USA I am stared at, cussed at and things like this. And attacted twice just for the scare I wear on my head. Thank you media for this !!!!
If only the media would start printing the similarities about the religion of Christians, Jews and Muslims. Instead of trying to show such a difference. We all want the right to worship our God as our religions request us to do. We all want a peaceful life. We all want to love and respect our parents. We all want the right to raise our children to love God. We all want a good quality of life by working hard. We all are taught to stay away from evil. IF WE PRACTICED OUR RELIGIONS FAITHFULLY (ISLAM, JUDISM, CHRISTIANITY, OTHER RELIGIONS) THERE WOULD BE NO WAR, NO SUICIDE BOMBINGS, THINGS OF THIS NATURE !!! THERE WOULD BE LESS PEOPLE STARVING IN THE WORLD AND HOMELESS. WE WOULD LIVE IN PEACE WITH OUR NEIGHBORS!!!
Aishah this is truly a good article. And yes I agree bringing up the Priests would take away from the whole point of your article. Which is...Islam and the truth of Heaven of which the Imam was definately not allowed to bring out by the time editing was done.
We need to pray for our media leaders...if only more positive stories were printed in this world, peoople would have the hope that our God allows us !!!
Assalam alaikum
ReplyDeleteI too had seen the TV broadcast of
this and had hoped to see
some 'good' points for Islam.
Well, as many of you had said...
it was a bit disapointing that
editing has taken the place of
truth and free speech. Isn't it
amazing how careful editing has
turned the story upon itself. The
iman was an intelligent man, who
seems to want to educate people -
but the editors/producers of the
show seemed to want to just
further the misconception of
Islam. Well so be it... all we
can pray for is that a few people
were enlightened to what true
Islam is.